Quoth the critic: ‘Nevermore’
Christian Bale has a face made for gothic. At this stage of his profession—36 years after his youthful look in Steven Spielberg’s battle drama, Empire of the Solar—Bale’s display screen presence has a sure care-worn cragginess about it. And judging from the roles he appears to have chosen recently, the bodily cragginess usually has a moderately preoccupied, even somber, inside attribute to accompany it, as if the actor’s onscreen adversities have someway change into a everlasting a part of the package deal.
With that in thoughts, a literary/historic melodrama like Scott Cooper’s The Pale Blue Eye makes a certain quantity of sense for the actor. It’s a fictionalized homicide thriller involving individuals in and round the US Navy Academy at West Level in 1830, together with a personal detective named Augustus Landor (Bale) and a lonely misfit among the many corps of cadets, one Edgar Allan Poe (Harry Melling). In idea, unusual issues would occur and Bale’s character might doggedly uncover the reality and convey the killer(s) to justice, with enter from the Divine Edgar. Sadly, the movie has issues.
Somebody is killing West Level cadets in gruesomely violent methods, and the academy’s officers are apprehensive that the crimes are sullying the repute of the comparatively new armed forces establishment. As in all too many mysteries, the detective doggedly makes the rounds—on this case, New York’s Hudson River Valley, really shot on location in snowy Pittsburgh, PA—whereas interacting with many of the possible suspects. For a film constructed alongside such slender traces, The Pale Blue Eye boasts a beneficiant solid of veteran character actors, all gussied up of their early-Nineteenth-century duds and hamming away at a managed boil.
West Level’s superintendent Thayer (whiskery, grumpy Timothy Spall) and his adjutant, Capt. Hitchcock (Simon McBurney, shifty-eyed as normal), are inclined to harrumph loudly whereas doing little or no investigating. Capt. Hitchcock is the proud proprietor of probably the most stilted traces, with supply to match—though Melling’s Poe can also be a number one contender. The academy doctor, Dr. Marquis (Toby Jones), scowls always, and the opposite characters are likely to strut round officiously or else slowly look at the floorboards, like Landor the sleuth. The tempo is glacial.
Solely Mrs. Marquis, the physician’s spouse (Gillian Anderson), has the ability to rescue the movie together with her outrageous outbursts—they’re the few scenes that provide any unpredictability. The physician’s daughter, a cultured blond (Lucy Boynton), appears to heat to the overall melancholy, then immediately faints. West Level is a fortress of responsible secrets and techniques.
In a extra typical tribute to the creator of “The Raven,” army misfit Poe could be the middle of the motion, however writer-director Cooper (Hostiles, Black Mass, Loopy Coronary heart), adapting Louis Bayard’s 2006 novel, appears unwilling to completely carry out the inherent grotesquery in actor Melling’s pale, haunted options. The true-life cadet Poe was nicely famous for his disciplinary troubles. Left to his personal gadgets right here, this Poe largely drinks and recites poetry.
Harry Potter alumnus Melling (additionally memorable from The Tragedy of Macbeth and The Ballad of Buster Scruggs), it ought to be mentioned, must be positioned right into a situation fastidiously, earlier than he wilts. He wouldn’t final a minute in a scene reverse Vincent Value. However wait, there are extra function gamers: Robert Duvall as scholarly witch hunter Prof. Jean Pépé; Charlotte Gainsbourg as Patsy the barmaid, the native strumpet; and Hadley Robinson within the shadowy function of Mattie, detective Landor’s late lamented daughter, a serious determine in his desires.
The much less mentioned in regards to the movie’s clumsy makes an attempt to hyperlink its characters to E.A. Poe’s precise works, the higher. The Pale Blue Eye, a nasty film encumbered by a superb solid, most likely got here throughout higher in define than it does onscreen. Earlier than the plot immediately tromps closely into the horror realm within the fourth quarter, it’s a plain, odd, morbid whodunit, with loads of darkish rooms and odd faces, and literary inclinations it by no means fairly takes benefit of.
* * *
Streaming on Netflix