Bay Space bakery Pacific Coast Baking has been stealing plastic bread trays from a rival to realize a aggressive benefit, a brand new lawsuit claims.
Fresno firm Athens Baking Firm, which delivers freshly baked items all through California and frozen merchandise throughout the U.S., alleged within the swimsuit filed this week that South San Francisco’s Pacific Coast, which delivers to a few hundred prospects within the Bay Space, has been intentionally snatching Athens’ plastic supply trays — and Athens claimed it has photographic proof to show it.
“We’re not speaking about remoted incidents – we’re speaking in regards to the ongoing, systematic theft of a whole lot of bread trays … sufficient to fill a semitrailer,” the lawsuit filed Monday in San Mateo County Superior Courtroom alleged.
Included within the swimsuit are two pictures exhibiting what Athens claims are its trays inside Pacific Coast’s loading dock in South San Francisco. Among the trays pictured bear Athens’ identify.
The swimsuit alleged that Pacific Coast proprietor Invoice Esposto denied figuring out why Athens’ trays have been allegedly on his loading dock. “I requested my drivers, ‘The place are we getting all these trays?’ the swimsuit claimed Esposto mentioned.
Esposto reportedly mentioned his supply drivers see prospects throw away different corporations’ trays as a result of these corporations’ drivers don’t decide them up. “We put them again within the system,” Esposto mentioned, in keeping with the swimsuit.
Athens mentioned it didn’t purchase Esposto’s reported rationalization.
“These are blatant lies,” the swimsuit mentioned.
Athens alleged that Pacific Coast has been stealing the trays for its personal use to chop prices, and to spice up bills for Athens and achieve a aggressive benefit.
Esposto countered that it’s truly the opposite means round. In a cellphone interview, he referred to as Athens a “gorilla” pounding its chest that “desires to crush us.”
Lacking trays are a long-standing consequence of getting totally different corporations delivering baked items to the identical prospects, as occurs amongst dairy corporations with milk crates, Esposto mentioned. “They get blended up,” he mentioned. “I’m lacking 1000’s of trays similar to they’re.”
“We don’t advocate that our drivers take any trays,” he mentioned. “We’re not on the market following vans round stealing trays. I’d wish to know the place my 3,000 trays are. They’re on the market someplace.”
Athens, Esposto believes, shouldn’t be coaching its drivers to choose up its personal trays. “It’s unhappy,” mentioned Esposto, who has been in enterprise for greater than 40 years.
He acknowledged Athens contacted him in regards to the trays within the Pacific Coast loading dock. “I referred to as them up and mentioned, ‘Ship somebody over to get your trays,’ they usually did,” he mentioned. “We despatched them an apology.”
Athens is searching for greater than an apology. The corporate’s lawsuit calls for important dough, claiming $45,000 in damages. The Fresno bread maker additionally desires a court docket order stopping Pacific Coast from “trafficking within the bread trays which have been stolen.”
Esposto mentioned he’ll pay his lawyer to battle the lawsuit, however needs he wouldn’t should.
“I don’t wish to spend the cash,” he mentioned. “I may very well be shopping for extra trays, and so may they.”